Naughty n Nice Wonka Factory Milkshake Martini

Naughty n Nice Wonka Factory Milkshake Martini

With the weather warming up, some are worrying about swimsuit season. I say why bother? It’s more like high time to be thinking about ice cream. This over-the-top boozy milkshake combines basically anything you could ever want or need in a dessert into one two-faced drink. On one side cake batter ice cream meets jelly beans, Starburst, white chocolate, sprinkles and some crazy fruity rainbow candy cane. On the other, chocolate hazelnut gelato mixes with vodka, truffles, Oreos, hot cocoa and mini chocolate chips. Dear God, what have I done? Enjoy them separately or all buddy-buddy.

This recipe has been submitted to Our Growing Edge. This month is hosted by Jordan from Vermilion Red. The theme is FLAVOURS YOU’VE GROWN TO LOVE. Since I’ve grown to love the taste of vodka!

The Nice side is centered around a limited edition Ben & Jerry’s ice cream flavor, Cake My Day. (See recipe for substitution, if necessary.) I picked it up on a whim as I’d originally been planning on mixing some funfetti cake mix with vanilla ice cream. But this is clearly the better option. Vanilla cake batter ice cream complete with cake bits, buttercream frosting and a raspberry swirl. Honestly, this ice cream didn’t need much help but you know how we roll here at SweetMeets. So I also added strawberry-flavored jelly beans and citrus-flavored Starburst fruit chews. Then I threw in that cake mix anyway plus some white chocolate, for good measure. This resulted in  a pleasantly fruity, adorably pink cake batter shake that I garnished with tons of sprinkles and a fruity candy cane. She’s nice and sweet but still a little quirky.

The Naughty side may be a little rough around the edges but we still love her. I had seen a couple commercials for Breyer’s new line, Gelato Indulgences, and good job ad execs because you  convinced me to buy a container. I used chocolate hazelnut flavor which comes with its own chocolate hazelnut sauce and convenient chocolate swirls on top. I amped it up by adding basically an entire box of specialty chocolates, some hot cocoa mix and a few filled cupcake Oreos that have both chocolate and vanilla filling. For a little bite, I also added a shot of chocolate and caramel flavored vodka. Then I dressed her up with a little hot fudge sauce, mini chocolate chips and a couple more truffles. She’s ready for a night on the town.

Who would’ve guessed two girls with such different tastes would become such good friends? They compliment each other so well. It’s a beautiful thing. Although, I think Naughty may be rubbing off on Nice a little…

Submitted to FiestaFriday 116.Your co-hosts this week are Judi @ cookingwithauntjuju and Cynthia @ eatmunchlove.

Other bipolar sweets and unique mashups:

6a00d8358081ff69e201a511a92fe2970c-800wi Strawberry Shortcake Donuts from A Beautiful Mess

smores31 Chocolate Chip Smore’s Bars from Mommity

IMG_7953-2-1024x768 Two-Face Cupcakes from Gringalicious

Snickers-12-White-645x429 Snickers Ice Cream Brownie Bites from Brit + Co

Naughty n Nice Wonka Factory Milkshake Martini

  • Servings: 2 large
  • Time: 15 minutes
  • Difficulty: easy
  • Print


Nice Side:

1 cup Ben & Jerry’s Cake My Day ice cream (or vanilla ice cream with 2 tablespoons yellow or funfetti cake crumbs, 2 tablespoons yellow or funfetti cake mix, 1 tablespoon raspberry preserves and 1 tablespoon vanilla buttercream frosting)

3 tablespoons milk

¼ cup strawberry jelly beans

¼ cup orange and yellow Starburst fruit chews

1 oz white chocolate

2 tablespoons funfetti cake mix

Naughty Side:

1 cup chocolate hazelnut Breyer’s Gelato Indulgences (or chocolate ice cream plus 3 tablespoons Nutella and 1 tablespoon chocolate chips)

9 assorted chocolate truffles or filled chocolates

3 filled cupcake Oreos

2 tablespoons chocolate and caramel flavored/candy bar vodka

2 tablespoons hot cocoa mix


2 wide straws

4-6 assorted chocolate truffles or filled chocolates


2 rainbow swirled candy sticks

Fudge sauce

Mini chocolate chips


Combine all Nice ingredients in a blender and run until smooth.

Move to pouring container and leave in the freezer.

Combine all Naughty ingredients in a blender and run until smooth.

Move to freezer while you prepare your glasses.

Slide the truffles onto each straw.

Wet half the rim of each glass with water and press on sprinkles.

Cover other half of rim with fudge sauce and press on chocolate chips.

Pouring is a little tricky. For best results, each flavor should be as similar in temperature and consistency as possible.

Hold one flavor’s container in each hand. Slowly and carefully pour both flavors into the serving glass at the same time, aiming for opposite sides of the glass.

Add candy sticks to Nice side and straws to Naughty side.

Serve immediately.

4 thoughts on “Naughty n Nice Wonka Factory Milkshake Martini

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s